Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Questions and Discussions about registry, rules and beagle field trialing in AKC. ARHA/NKC, CKC-Can, CKC-USA, PKC and UKC, etc.

Moderators: Pike Ridge Beagles, Aaron Bartlett

User avatar
mike crabtree
Posts: 3197
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:58 pm
Location: Wytheville VA
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by mike crabtree »

mike crabtree wrote:Chief, I agree with most of what you have said, but to me Jumping a rabbit is the most important part. Here where I am from they are hard to find, and buried deep in black berry briars. You wont jump many yourself here.In Indiana you are very blessed with rabbits, so a Jump probably isnt that Important.

As for UKC goes on the Jump. A dog that barks 1st gets the most points in a strike situation. More often than not a dog besides the 1st to bark actually jumps the rabbit.

I have hunted all 3 formats talked about. Im batting higher in UKC than any of them. The competition isnt near as tough as ARHA, or AKC. I havent won any AKC Hunts I only entered 2, but could tell more of the dogs were there to win, not just be there.
Chief, Here I quoted myself from the earlier post If you read it all this time you will probably feel like a real dumbazz for smarting off to me. I actually said someyhing negative about UKC and something Positive about AKC. Try reading someones post before you get all high and mighty. :baby:
Wanna run Dogs? U R Invited.
276 620 1572

User avatar
Chief Long Hair
Posts: 482
Joined: Fri Apr 04, 2003 8:42 pm
Location: Greenwood, IN

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Chief Long Hair »

The competition isnt near as tough as ARHA, or AKC.
I'm sorry. I admit that I read it wrong. I accidentally read it to mean that UKC was tougher. (Does it show that I don't care much for a certain format?) I took the second "as" in your quote and made it a "in". MY BAD! I gues I ned two goe bac to engrish class, (maybe take the short bus too). By the way, that was my toughest, most hated class in high school for me. I guess that makes me a "dumbazz".

I hope you're going to Schumaker's farm again this year. Look me up, I'll be there and I'll apologize in person.

Sorry again,
Da Chief
I'VE GOT SOME DOGS THAT ARE GONNA HURT SOME FEELINGS!!!!! I just hope it's not mine. Home of Wild Hare Kennels and FC Creek Woods Blue.

rabbitearl
Posts: 1024
Joined: Fri Apr 04, 2008 10:32 am

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by rabbitearl »

I understand chief.I ve hosted And akc and done three years of ARHA as pres.till someone came down and had to show his tell.We like Arha but after that the ##ll with that.Don t know nothing about UKC.But in AKC spo I recken thats what you run in.But tell me Why is it that one spo club likes slower dogs and then some clubs like faster dogs.Some say that a FC spo dog can be different than night and day.Don t everybody have the same rule book?And without thinking about it can you say all akc FC are great rabbit dogs.
We done a jump dog trial one time.Had 18 dogs in it.Out of 18 dogs we had only three to find a rabbit in a 3 ac pen with only 5 rabbits in it in 10 min, planted in it.There was some guys that thought they had a jump dog.Thinking you have one a having one is two different thing.How about it Chief how many jump dogs do you have?

User avatar
Jeremy Mapes
Posts: 741
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 3:36 pm
Location: N.E. Indiana
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Jeremy Mapes »

To say that hunt is over rated, is absolutely crazy. If a rabbit isn't jumped there is nothing to run. I'll say it again "You don't need a dog if you're jumping the rabbits for them!" Hell anybody can get his buddy to jump on a brushpile while he waits for the rabbit to come out so he can shoot it, but what's the fun in that. Yes I know once the rabbit's up you have to have a track dog, but a track dog does no good without there being a jumped rabbit. In my area there aren't a lot of places to hunt where a person can go out and jump rabbits for the dogs. You might jump a couple, but with a jump dog you will likely triple the amount chases you get.
I'm not saying that AKC isn't tough, because I know it is. I've ran with a lot of AKC FC's and have been impressed and I've ran with some other ones that didn't impress me. The ones that didn't impress me didn't hunt and didn't act like they knew how to jump a rabbit. All formats have their ups and downs. Another thing I noticed about AKC is the amount of mouth they allow a dog to use. It might just be a coincidence but it seems to me that most of the successful AKC dogs I've seen were a little mouthy before the jump.
The reason I run UKC the most is that UKC trials are what's around me. I'd like to hunt more AKC but unfortunately I just can't afford the travel. I do think that AKC for the most part is harder to win in.
Dry Creek Kennel-Bred to get it done where it counts the most "under the gun".
RIP FC Buckeye's Big John
PCH HBCH Dry Creek Stroke Of Genius
DCK Bounty Hunter
DCK Queen Of The Cage (Rousey)

Mapel Valley Kennels LLC.
Posts: 3877
Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:40 pm
Location: Great State Of Kentucky

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Mapel Valley Kennels LLC. »

Jeremy.
I dont have a beef with ukc, just not heard anything much to it. If the handlers call dogs thats pretty cool if honesty prevails.I dont like the part about a judge being in my cast and calling his dog but whatever. As far as dogs being mouthy in akc? There is good and bad in all.I consider my hounds tight mouth but thats just a plus of t-rex hounds. I still stamp my approval on good hard hunt. in any format. In my eyes hunt is the first thing i breed for without hunt and heart you have 0. Cant be taught, they eiether got it or dont.
When the moment of truth arrives, the point of preparation has passed.
Old School, Full Throttle ,No Bottle.

User avatar
Chief Long Hair
Posts: 482
Joined: Fri Apr 04, 2003 8:42 pm
Location: Greenwood, IN

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Chief Long Hair »

IMHO "jumping the rabbit" is just a very small part of the overall picture here. I've seen a few dogs who can jump one but gets it's butt kicked every where else. It's not that important except for getting a score or "getting a dog out of your way" in some formats and that's it. While hunting for food on the table, the ability to "jump" doesn't help that much. It's simple. Get a rabbit up by any means and get the dogs on it if they're not. Stand still for a while and guess what? If you've got decent dogs and you're a good shot, BOOM, you've got food for the table. Jump ability is over rated.
I'll say it again, the ability to jump is way over rated. Check work, line control, speed, control of speed, brains, hunt, all these rate higher in my book. If any one of those are missing you'll have a tough day hunting whether your dog can jump or not. Even correct use of mouth, endurance or stamina, willing to work as a pack, rates just as high if not higher than jump.
Jeremy Mapes, you would make an excellent politician looking at the way how you spin peoples words. The proof in that is shown above in red. That is two actual quotes from me. I said "JUMP" not "HUNT". There is a difference. You've seen it where one dog beats the brush to submission while another is much more methodical. Both are good in my book. Just like what Mike Crabtree said to me:
Chief, Here I quoted myself from the earlier post If you read it all this time you will probably feel like a real dumbazz for smarting off to me. I actually said someyhing negative about UKC and something Positive about AKC. Try reading someones post before you get all high and mighty.
NOUGH SAID.

rabbitearl To answer your first question, AKC rules are more vague than any other format. Here’s an example taken out of the:

Beagle
Field Trial Rules
And Standard Procedures for
Brace, Small Pack
and Small Pack Option
Field Trials and Two-Couple
Pack Hunting Tests
Amended to March 2007
Published by The American Kennel Club

GENERAL PROCEDURES GOVERNING
BEAGLE FIELD TRIALS

PROCEDURE 5. STANDARD FOR JUDGING

5-B Definitions—Desirable Qualities

Pursuing ability is shown by a proficiency for
keeping control of the trail while making the best possible
progress. Game should be pursued rather than
merely followed, and actions should indicate a determined
effort to make forward progress in the surest,
most sensible manner by adjusting speed to correspond
to conditions and circumstances. Actions
should be positive and controlled, portraying sound
judgment and skill. Progress should be proclaimed by
tonguing. No hound can be too fast, provided the trail
is clearly and accurately followed
. At a check, hounds
should work industriously, first close to where the
loss occurred, then gradually and thoroughly extending
the search further afield to regain the line.

Accuracy in trailing is the ability to keep consistent
control of the trail while making the best possible
progress. An accurate trailing hound will show a
marked tendency to follow the trail with a minimum of
weaving on and off, and will display an aptness to turn
with the trail and to determine direction of game travel
in a positive manner.

Here’s a link to their rule book:

http://www.akc.org/pdfs/rulebooks/RF2404.pdf (The rules for judging a dog starts on page 19.)

In other words it’s up to the judges on how they interpret the words “No hound can be too fast, provided the trail is clearly and accurately followed” . UBGF judges, slow dogs, want a dog that straddles the line and very close to the check while Mid-West, fast dogs, is a little more forgiving. Both types of dogs progress the rabbit. Just like us, it’s all what you like.

My partners and I have 14 dogs among all three of us. To answer your second question, one partner has six dogs. Two are pets, one being a Pit Bull and the other a beagle that means a lot to him. I have no idea how much "jump" ability they both have. I'd say the Pit Bull "don't need any"! I jump when I see him! Does that count? The other four dogs consist of two of which I'd say has "jump" to the max while the other two are slower in hunt but are more methodical than the first two.

The other partner has seven beagles. One is nothing more than a pet and has yet to be giving a chance to see what it could do. Of the six remaining, at least one has "jump", two are more methodical, two are still being evaluated and one is just a pup.

Me? I have one old maid who I would say she had "jump" in her day but she is now just a pet. Problem was she'd jump more than just rabbits.

To end this, I breed for "hunt" in my dogs hoping to get "jump" but it's not necessary. There is a difference. If I have a dog with no-hunt, he/she is gone with lead poisoning of the brain at a high rate of speed.
I'VE GOT SOME DOGS THAT ARE GONNA HURT SOME FEELINGS!!!!! I just hope it's not mine. Home of Wild Hare Kennels and FC Creek Woods Blue.

User avatar
Jeremy Mapes
Posts: 741
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 3:36 pm
Location: N.E. Indiana
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Jeremy Mapes »

LOL! Not the first time I've heard that. I strive the type of dog that can do it all, but jump is the most important to me. IMO jumph and hunt go hand n hand. If a dog has enough hunt and gets enough ground time it will make a good jump dog.
Dry Creek Kennel-Bred to get it done where it counts the most "under the gun".
RIP FC Buckeye's Big John
PCH HBCH Dry Creek Stroke Of Genius
DCK Bounty Hunter
DCK Queen Of The Cage (Rousey)

Mapel Valley Kennels LLC.
Posts: 3877
Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:40 pm
Location: Great State Of Kentucky

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Mapel Valley Kennels LLC. »

Jeremy, Just a quick look at ur website.Pretty nice.How many of these hounds were you the breeder of.??
When the moment of truth arrives, the point of preparation has passed.
Old School, Full Throttle ,No Bottle.

User avatar
Jeremy Mapes
Posts: 741
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 3:36 pm
Location: N.E. Indiana
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Jeremy Mapes »

I don't have any hounds on the website. These are my buddies dogs. I've bred a litter of Turbo crossed over the White River stuff with good success. At one year old a female is a ukc dual champ and two other dogs have places, I'm pretty sure one of them has a first. The male I just bred to is on there. I haven't bred a lot of this line but have run with a ton of dogs from it. Were gonna try a few outcrosses this year and see how it goes. I've had good success with past crosses similar to Daisy on the site as well, but I'm not the breeder of any on there.
Dry Creek Kennel-Bred to get it done where it counts the most "under the gun".
RIP FC Buckeye's Big John
PCH HBCH Dry Creek Stroke Of Genius
DCK Bounty Hunter
DCK Queen Of The Cage (Rousey)

Mapel Valley Kennels LLC.
Posts: 3877
Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 4:40 pm
Location: Great State Of Kentucky

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by Mapel Valley Kennels LLC. »

Jeremy Mapes wrote:I don't have any hounds on the website. These are my buddies dogs. I've bred a litter of Turbo crossed over the White River stuff with good success. At one year old a female is a ukc dual champ and two other dogs have places, I'm pretty sure one of them has a first. The male I just bred to is on there. I haven't bred a lot of this line but have run with a ton of dogs from it. Were gonna try a few outcrosses this year and see how it goes. I've had good success with past crosses similar to Daisy on the site as well, but I'm not the breeder of any on there.
I filling what you say but if a 1 year old pup is winning and placing how hard could it be? I have seen as years go past young dogs trialed at a young age, just never made any sense to me. Back to breeding , its all in the pudding and until you have spent several years at it, success is rare. White river must be the turbo of ukc everyone seems to drive it.Me pesonally i decided years ago to go the other way and try something everyone does not have, guess its boring if we all think alike.I wish you success in whatever you trial but in oct i would like the chance to see ya at the coal mine classic.Bring the pup i may have one of mine to drop on ya.on.
:shock: Peace Jimbo
When the moment of truth arrives, the point of preparation has passed.
Old School, Full Throttle ,No Bottle.

eddywilliams
Posts: 3298
Joined: Mon May 15, 2006 4:13 pm
Location: ohio

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by eddywilliams »

I enjoy most Ukc hunts there are a lot of them within an hour of me ,akc not so many ,but I will say I want a jumpdog 1St and foremost ,a lot of dogs might not be the total package and when I turn 1 loose alone or in company it best be going to find a rabbit not lurking waiting for Tally Ho or Here it is or another dog to bark .
Last edited by eddywilliams on Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
RABBIT RIDGE KENNELS :
HOME OF:
IFC BEAVER CREEKS KICK AZ
FCGD THOMPSONS TRY MY PATIENCE
OUTBACK MATILDA
RABBIT RIDGE ONE TUFF AZ KICKER
RABBIT RIDGE PARIS
http://rabbitridgekennels.webs.com/

User avatar
mike crabtree
Posts: 3197
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:58 pm
Location: Wytheville VA
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by mike crabtree »

Chief,

That was good enuff for me. I dont know when Ill get to another AKC Trial, they are a long way away.Ive got 1 or 2 that may be able to do something, but Wurtland is 3.5 hours. Schumachers is about 5 hours. I liked the way things were handled better up there, and 10 times the game.
Wanna run Dogs? U R Invited.
276 620 1572

MikeSmithWV
Posts: 218
Joined: Fri Aug 02, 2002 7:05 am
Location: Clothier, WV
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by MikeSmithWV »

Mike, Pliny, WV has an AKC trial coming up and should only be 2 hrs at the most from you..

Mike
"But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." Romans 5:8

User avatar
mike crabtree
Posts: 3197
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:58 pm
Location: Wytheville VA
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by mike crabtree »

MikeWV, Is that 2 hours from Wytheville?? It takes me 2 hours and 14 minutes to get to Charleston.
Wanna run Dogs? U R Invited.
276 620 1572

MikeSmithWV
Posts: 218
Joined: Fri Aug 02, 2002 7:05 am
Location: Clothier, WV
Contact:

Re: Which is harder to win in, ARHA, UKC, or AKC.

Post by MikeSmithWV »

Probobly 2 hrs and 45 minutes then...lol, sorrry A little closer than Wurtland though...
"But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." Romans 5:8

Post Reply