I love how the male dog gets all the credit, good or bad, lol. Even if he's just a grandsire one time in a dog's pedigree, any traits exhibited by said dog must without fail, be attributed to the well-known grandsire or sire, etc. Forget the other 31 dogs in the pedigree...it's
ALL GRANDADDY'S FAULT.....(lol).
I don't have any direct experience with Ali-Baba, but my dogs have had their asses handed to them by a lot of his direct offspring. Mystery Man, for one. I had another friend on this board (an old hound guy who's hard to fool) say that although Ali-Baba was a good dog, his favorite of all Branko dogs was a direct son, Baba Cowboy. When topics like this come up and I don't have a lot of first-hand experience, I don't put in much, but I tend to take the common sense route before making "guess"itmations. Add up all the facts and factors and then decide.
1. No dog is perfect. Even those that seem perfect do strange things from time to time...especially when they are very young or very old, so consider the age of the dog you're evaluating.
2. Not all world-beaters are producers. Some average dogs are super producers, almost always throwing dogs better than themselves (I love it when this happens). There will only be one Ali-Baba, but there can be many offspring. If the majority of the offspring do well, especially given the diversity of the dams involved, one can say his overall contribution to the sport/breed was good.
3. Not all good producers will nick with everything. Even the best dog to the best bitch will often produce a disappointing litter. If this hasn't happened to you, you haven't bred enough dogs yet.
4. Consider the people behind the dogs. From the small amount of time I have been around the Krpans or talked them on the phone, or e-mailed back and forth with Frieda, I can tell you with no uncertainty that Branko will not hesitate to put a dog in the ground if it consistently shows a serious fault
during his watch. As many good or "famous" dogs that have come from Brankos Beagles, you can bet a bunch more didn't make Branko's cut. It may seem by sheer numbers that they are putting everything they breed out on the circuit, but this is not the case. It's just that most of us don't have the facility, land, or time to produce dogs in the same numbers. There must be something redeeming about a dog for it to remain in their kennel...especially to die there as an old dog, and have straws drawn.
Everything being said, I'd say he was the real deal -- either as a hound or a reproducer, or both. Was he perfect? Most likely not, but he definitely made his mark on the sport. Not everyone will like a particular dog, or they will witness things that flat turn them off. For all the people who live and die by Turbo blood, I can give you a handful that wouldn't have it in their kennels. To each his own.
Look at the overall impact, not just one or two opinions because nobody can be everywhere all the time. Don't take the opinion of someone who "judged him at a trial one time" and make an assumption that the dog was 100% of who he was that day.
